April 30, 2022

Best Classical and Early Romantic Piano Concertos

The piano was invented in Italy around the year 1700 by Bartolomeo Cristofori (1655-1731). Christofori switched the plucking mechanism of the harpsichord to one with a hammer, enabling the musician to exercise control over the volume of the sound. The instrument was called "clavicembalo col piano e forte" ("harpsichord that can play soft and loud"), which was shorted to "fortepiano" and later "piano." 

 [Instrument by Christofori]

Cristofori's instrument spread at first quite slowly, probably because, being more elaborate and harder to build than a harpsichord, it was rather expensive. The first solo music specifically written for the instrument dates from 1732 but was still an isolated phenomenon as the fortepiano at that time remained something exotic. The fortepiano did not achieve full popularity until the 1760s, from which time date the first public performances; this was also the time that music described as being for the fortepiano was first widely published. 

Christofori's invention was copied and improved on by German instrument builders as Gottfried Silbermann, who built an instrument played by Bach in 1747. 

[Square piano by Zumpe] 

Next, in the 1760s, a German instrument maker working in London, Johannes Zumpe. built inexpensive "square pianos," which had horizontal strings arranged diagonally across the rectangular case above the hammers and with the keyboard set in the long side, with the sounding board above a cavity in the short side. Damping had to be done manually, by manipulating levers when a hand happened to be free. This meant that notes would ring on (as there would not always be a hand free), creating a halo of resonance. That however exactly fits the music written for this instrument, which took this feature into account and sounds "bare" when played on a more modern piano. The square piano dominated the London piano market for about 15 years. 

These square pianos formed the medium for which the first concertos for piano and string ensemble were written by composers as Johann Christian Bach and Carl Friedrich Abel in about 1770. The piano concerto was born!

[Broadwood piano]   

Later, John Broadwood in England added improvements to the English action that Zumpe invented, increasing the elasticity of the strings, and also strengthening the frame. His English action (in around 1780) produced a touch with a lower sense of resistance and a more powerful sound. In that regard, this instrument can be termed the precursor to the modern piano. In his later years, Beethoven wrote many masterpieces on this piano made by Broadwood.
 
Development also continued in Vienna, where Johann Andreas Stein (1728-1792) developed what would later be called the Viennese action, which was responsible for a brighter tone and which responded well to the player's touch. Musicians such as Mozart, Haydn, Hummel, and the young Beethoven played these early Viennese instruments and helped increase the demand for them. These Stein pianos were light and playing them required exquisite sensitivity of touch rather than strength. Stein's business was carried on in Vienna by his daughter Nannette Streicher along with her husband Johann Andreas Streicher. The two were friends of Beethoven, and one of the composer's pianos was a Streicher. Later on in the early 19th century, more robust instruments with greater range were built in Vienna, by amongst others the Streicher firm and by Graf. Another important Viennese builder was Anton Walter, a friend of Mozart who built instruments with a somewhat more powerful sound than Stein's (Mozart owned an instrument by Walter). Composers and pianists in Vienna and beyond continued to use the Viennese piano through the middle of the 19th century, with such famous musicians as Schubert, Mendelssohn, Chopin, Schumann, Kalkbrenner, Liszt, and Brahms all playing or owning instruments of the Viennese style. 

[Piano by Stein]

During the second half of the 19th c., the English action pianos, especially as perfected by American firms as Steinway, came to dominate the world market for pianos. Bösendorfer was the last major company to make pianos with the Viennese action, but switched to the more common English action in the early twentieth century.

To return to the piano concerto: after its birth in London in the hands of two German composers, during the Classical era the form quickly took hold across Europe, especially in Germany and Austria, becoming established with works by Mozart, and to a lesser degree Haydn, Stamitz, and Wölfl. In the early Romantic period the piano concerto repertoire was added to most notably by Beethoven, Schumann, Mendelssohn, Chopin, Hummel, Ries, and Field.

[JC Bach]

(1) Johann Christian Bach: Keyboard Concerto in E flat major, Op 7 No 5 (1770)
The piano concerto was born in London around 1770, inspired by a revolutionary new instrument so delicate it could only be accompanied by a string trio (not so strange, for this was also the form in which piano concertos in the 18th c. were performed when played in the home). That was the square piano built by Zumpe, as described above. One of the earliest composers for this instrument was Bach's eleventh son, Johann Christian.

Johann Christian Bach (1735-1782) left his town of birth, Leipzig, for Milan where he composed operas. In 1762 he moved to London, where he became the Queen's Music Master, and became known as "the London Bach." In 1764 Bach spent five months teaching composition to the visiting Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, who was aged eight at the time and had been brought to London by his father. When Mozart began writing piano concertos in 1765, he adapted JC Bach's keyboard sonatas as his early concertos (K37-K41).

JC Bach's set of 6 keyboard concertos op 7 was published in London in 1770 and dedicated to the Queen. The fifth concerto, in three movements, is the finest of the set, featuring a deeply-felt slow movement in C minor. The first movement is in conventional classical form; the development begins with the soloist introducing new material, a procedure typical of Mozart but (as is obvious here) started by JC Bach! The cheerful last movement is superficially simple but contains various interesting compositional devices.
[Performance listened to: The World’s First Piano Concertos, with David Owen Norris, piano, and Sonnerie on Avie]


(2) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart: Piano Concerto No. 5 in D major, K. 175 (1773)
Piano Concerto No. 5 in D major, KV 175, is Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's de facto first piano concerto. He wrote the three-movement work at the age of seventeen in Salzburg. It is not an apprentice work, for the style is clearly Mozart and the ideas are attractive and skillfully organized. Mozart himself must have liked the concerto, for he kept it in his repertory for over a decade. Mozart probably composed the concerto for his own use and that of his sister at house or court concerts during Carnival and Lent. He took it on a tour to Munich in 1774, and to Mannheim and Paris in 1777-78. For a Lenten concert in Vienna Mozart composed a new rondo finale in 1785 (K 382), but that is usually played as a separate piece nowadays. Mozart replaced a sonata-form movement in the learned style with a piece in the galant style, but the new rondo finale has also been called a "series of insipid variations" - it is "cute" in the worst sense of that word. Around 1785-86 the concerto was finally published, signalling the end of its usefulness to Mozart as a performance piece.  
[Performance listened to: Malcolm Binson with the English Baroque Soloists on Archiv Produktion]


(3) Antonio Salieri: Concerto for fortepiano and orchestra in B-flat major (1773)
Antonio Salieri (1750 – 1825) was an Italian composer from Legnago, south of Verona, in the Republic of Venice, who spent his adult life and career as a subject of the Habsburg monarchy in Vienna. Salieri was a pivotal figure in the development of late 18th-century opera. As a student of Florian Leopold Gassmann, and a protégé of Christoph Willibald Gluck, Salieri was a cosmopolitan composer who wrote operas in three languages. He helped to develop and shape many of the features of operatic compositional vocabulary, and his music exerted a powerful influence on contemporary composers. Salieri's small instrumental output includes two piano concerti, a concerto for organ written in 1773, a concerto for flute, oboe and orchestra (1774), and a triple concerto for oboe, violin and cello.
[Performance listened to: Andreas Staier and Concerto Koeln on Teldec]


(4) Carl Friedrich Abel
: Keyboard Concerto in B flat Op 11 No 2, WK 54 (1774)
Abel (1723-1787) was a German composer and virtuoso viola da gamba player who was a pupil of J.S. Bach at the St. Thomas School in Leipzig. After playing in the Dresden court orchestra (1743–58), Abel went to London, where in 1764 he set up London's first orchestral conscription concerts in the Hanover Square Rooms together with Bach's son Johann Christian. These concerts featured the first public performances in England of Joseph Haydn’s symphonies. Abel and Bach also befriended the young Mozart when he visited London. The Op 11 concertos, dating from the early 1770s were published in Amsterdam and London and keep to the early classical two movement structure. It is graceful music which while making mild demands on the fingers, musically proceeds into new regions of expressiveness. This concerto was originally written for the resonant "square piano."
[Performance listened to: The World’s First Piano Concertos, with David Owen Norris, piano, and Sonnerie on Avie]


(5) Joseph Haydn: Keyboard Concerto No. 11 in D major, Hob. XVIII/11 (1779-83, pub. 1784)
Of the 14 pieces for keyboard and orchestra in the list of Haydn's works, only three can confidently be considered as authentic, either by specific reference to the composer's own musical notebook or by the appearance of a published score during the composer's lifetime, as is the case with the present concerto. When it was published in 1784 the title page proudly proclaimed it to be "the only piano concerto of Haydn which so far has appeared in print." It was written when Haydn was already a European celebrity and was working on his string quartets op 33.
The concerto was originally composed for either harpsichord or fortepiano, but the slow second movement only works well on a fortepiano. The work opens with a bright Vivace in the strings, quickly joined by the winds, and later by the piano's cheerful contributions. The second movement Adagio is an elaborate melancholy aria for keyboard with the strings. The rousing final movement, headed Rondo all' Ungarese (although the folk-tune apparently is Croatian rather than Hungarian) sealed the concerto’s popularity in Haydn’s lifetime.
[Performance listened to: Marc-Andre Hamelin and Les Violons du Roy directed by Bernard Labadie]

(6) Ludwig van Beethoven: Piano Concerto in E-flat major, WoO 4 (1784, completed by Hess)
Ludwig van Beethoven's "lost" E flat major Piano concerto was written in 1784 when the composer was a mere fourteen years of age. Beethoven later disowned the piece, and the original orchestral parts were lost over time. When the work was rediscovered around 1890 only the solo piano part had survived intact. The reconstruction of the concerto came at the hand of musicologist Willy Hess, who drew on cues in the extant piano part to fashion the orchestration. While It is difficult to regard the E flat concerto as an authentic piano concerto by Beethoven, the parentage of the solo piano manuscript is undisputed.
[Performance listened to: Sophie Mayuko Vetter and the Hamburg Symphony Orchestra, Peter Ruzicka]

This very early Beethoven at Youtube played by Philippe Boaron and the Camerata du Léman:






(7) Johann Franz Xaver Sterkel: Piano Concerto No 2 in D major Op 26.1 (1785 or earlier)
Johann Franz Xaver Sterkel (1750 – 1817) was educated at the University of Würzburg and in 1778 he became chaplain and musician at the court in Mainz. He lived in Regensburg (from 1802 to 1810), then in Aschaffenburg, and finally retired to Würzburg in 1815. He had various posts as music director and Kapellmeister. He wrote mostly instrumental music, including symphonies (24) and concertos (6 for piano), chamber works with keyboard solo, piano sonatas and piano duets. In his piano concertos, Sterkel places the main importance on the musical action of the solo instrument, instead of opting for a dialogue between piano and orchestra.
[Performance listened to: Kai Adomeit and the Bohuslav-Martinu Philharmonic Zlin directed by Peter Luecker on Bayer Records]

(8) Leopold Kozeluch: Keyboard Concerto
in F major, Op 12 No 1 (1784 or 1785)
Kozeluch (1747-1818) was one of many 18th c. Czech musicians who moved to Vienna to staff the  musical households of the Hapsburg empire. In 1771 he made his debut with a ballet at the National Theater in Prague. In 1778 he left for Vienna and probably became a pupil of Johann Georg Albrechtsberger for a short time. Soon Kozeluch became a celebrated pianist. As successor to Georg Christoph Wagenseil, he became the teacher of Archduchess Maria Elisabeth, daughter of Empress Maria Theresa of Austria, at the imperial court.

After the death of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, he became chamber chapel master and court composer to Franz I of Austria in 1792. Even in his lifetime he was appreciated throughout Europe. His symphonies were performed several times by Joseph Haydn in London. As a composer he wrote around 400 works, including around 30 symphonies, 22 concertos for piano, 2 concertos for clarinet, 24 sonatas for piano and violin, 63 trios with piano, 2 oratorios, nine cantatas and various church music.

The piano concerto in F starts with an insistent melody that may keep humming around in your head. This is followed by a songful Adagio. The 6/8 tune of the final rondo turns into a dance.
[Performance listened to: Howard Shelley and the London Mozart Players on Hyperion]

(9) Carl Philip Stamitz: Keyboard Concerto in F major (1790)
Carl Philip Stamitz (1745-1801) was the most prominent representative of the second generation of the Mannheim School. His father was Konzertmeister of the court orchestra in Mannheim, and brought the Mannheim orchestra to an impressive peak of perfection. Carl studied with his father and with other members of the court orchestra, including Christian Cannabich, Ignaz Holzbauer, and Franz Xaver Richter. In 1770 he moved to Paris, where he was appointed court composer and regularly performed in the Concert spirituel. In 1780 Carl moved to The Hague where, between 1782 and 1784, he appeared, primarily as a violist, at twenty-eight concerts given at the court of William V, Prince of Orange. Between 1788 and 1790 he performed in a large number of German cities, before spending his last years in Jena, as Kapellmeister and teacher at the University.

Carl Stamitz's compositions include more than fifty symphonies, nearly forty symphonies concertantes (most of them with two solo instruments), some forty solo concertos, and a huge body of chamber music for strings and for winds, both separately and in combination. The piano concerto of Stamitz is based on a relatively conventional template, but has been invested with a new depth of expression designed to produce a new range of affections in the listener. This is the 'sentimental' style of composition that opened the door to Empfindsamkeit and to the Sturm and Drang movement most notably embodied by the mid-period symphonies of Haydn.
[Performance listened to: Elena Pinciaroli, piano, Rami Musicali Orchestra, Filippo Conti, conductor on Brilliant]

[Clementi]

(10) Muzio Clementi: Piano Concerto in C major (1796)
The Italian-born pianist and composer Muzio Clementi (1752-1832) from a young age had his base in London, although he made several concert tours on the continent as well. On one such occasion, in 1781, he engaged in a piano competition with Mozart. Influenced by the stile galante of Johann Christian Bach, Clementi developed a fluent legato style, which he passed on to a generation of pianists, including John Field, Johann Baptist Cramer, Ignaz Moscheles, Friedrich Kalkbrenner, Carl Czerny and others. Clementi also produced and promoted his own brand of pianos and was a notable music publisher.

Only one piano concerto by Clementi has come down to us. The first movement looks back to Mozart's early Salzburg concertos such as the concerto No 9 K271. The opening tutti presents all the first movement's main material - in contrast to Mozart's custom, the piano introduces no new melodies of its own. The second movement is a hushed Adagio with rapturous embellishments by the piano. The presto rondo finale is in the style of a contredanse, and provides a merry and playful conclusion.
[Performance listened to: Howard Shelley (piano and conductor) with the Sinfonieorchester St. Gallen on Hyperion]


(11) John Baptist Cramer: Piano Concerto No. 2 in D minor Op. 16 (1797)
John Baptist Cramer (1771-1758) was brought from Mannheim to London as a child by his violinist father, and as a virtuoso pianist, composer and music publisher, became one of the leading figures in British music. Cramer studied with Clementi, something which though brief was decisive in forming his artistic temperament. He made two long concert tours through the continent and in 1799 met Beethoven in Vienna. Besides being one of the finest pianists of his day, Cramer was a hugely prolific composer of 124 sonatas (of which 60 solo sonatas for the piano), as well as many pedagogic works.

Cramer wrote in all nine piano concertos, published over the thirty-year period 1795 to 1825. The second concerto is contemporaneous with Beethoven's first two. Like those, Cramer stays quite close to the format established by Mozart (his last two concertos would be more experimental). But also Cramer's early concertos contain very fine music.
[Performance listened to: Howard Shelley and the London Mozart Players]
 

(12) Daniel Steibelt: Piano Concerto No 3 in E major "L'orage", op.33 (1798)
Daniel Gottlieb Steibelt (1765-1823) was a German pianist and composer, who was mainly active in Paris, London and St Petersburg. As a fashionable virtuoso he scored great successes in these cities. But Steibelt seems to have been "vain, arrogant, and extravagant" - and he had to change his address frequently to keep ahead of his creditors. There also exists a famous anecdote how he was humiliated in a contest with Beethoven when he visited Vienna in 1800. But those things shouldn't obscure the fact that Steibelt was an imaginative composer - he wrote 8 piano concertos of which the last from 1820 even contains a chorus. In general, he focused his skill on pictorial effects, such as a storm, a hunt, a trip in the mountains and military music. These appear in his finales (his strongest movements) and are great fun. In contrast, the slow movements are short and relatively weak. In 1798 he produced his concerto No. 3 in E flat while working in London, where he had moved two years earlier. It became a work that instantly ensured his popularity. The most impressive movement is the final rondo pastorale, in which the famous storm occurs: after a quiet section (a sort of slow peasant dance), the composer introduces an effective, if somewhat naïve, imitation of a storm. The concerto was played in concert halls all over Europe. It is indeed a very enjoyable concerto, full of good tunes and keyboard gymnastics.
[Performance listened to: Ulster Orchestra/Howard Shelley (piano/conductor) on Hyperion]

[Dussek]


(13) Johann Ladislav Dussek: Piano Concerto No 10 in G minor, Op 49/50, (1801)
Johann Ladislav Dussek (1760-1812) was one of the first piano virtuosos to travel widely throughout Europe. He performed at courts and concert venues from London to St Petersburg to Milan, and was celebrated for his technical prowess. During a nearly ten-year stay in London, he was instrumental in extending the size of the pianoforte, and was the recipient of one of John Broadwood's first 6-octave pianos. He also was the first pianist to sit at the piano with his profile to the audience, earning him the appellation "le beau visage." All subsequent pianists have sat on stage in this manner. He was one of the best-regarded pianists in Europe before Beethoven's rise to prominence.

Numbering Dussek’s approximately eighteen piano concertos is a bit of a challenge. They span nearly a third of a century, with the earliest stemming from 1779 (when Dussek was nineteen), the last from about 1810, two years before his death at the age of fifty-two. His first and last attempts are lost, and at least three of the surviving concertos specify either pianoforte or harp. I have here selected the Piano Concerto in G Minor, Op. 49/50, the 10th piano concerto and Dussek's only concerto in a minor key. Although virtually unknown today, is considered one of the most important contributions to the genre in the transition from musical classicism to romanticism. Dussek probably began composing the concerto around 1799, when he left London, and completed it in Germany no later than 1801. In 1801, the work was published for the first time in Paris by Érard, in 1803 for the first time in London by Clementi & Co as op. 49, and shortly thereafter, in revised form, in Leipzig by Breitkopf & Härtel as op. 50.
[Performance listened to: Andreas Staier, Hammerfluegel, and the Concerto Koeln on Capriccio]


(14) Carolus Antonius Fodor: Keyboard Concerto in G minor, op 12 (1802)
Venlo-born Anton Fodor (1768-1846) was a pianist, conductor and composer, the best Dutch musician of his generation at a time that foreign musicians were dominant in the Netherlands. In 1801 he was named conductor of the orchestra of Felix Meritis in Amsterdam, a position he occupied for 25 years. Fodor's classical manner is close to that of Joseph Haydn. He wrote 8 piano concertos. The present one stems from 1802 and is especially attractive because of the sparkling "alla turque" rondo finale.
[Performance listened to: Arthur Schoonderwoerd with Christofori on Alpha]


(15) Joseph Woelfl: Piano Concerto No. 1 in G major, Op. 20 (1802-03)
Joseph Johann Baptist Woelfl (also written in the German form Wölfl, 1773-1812) was born in Salzburg, where he studied music under Leopold Mozart and Michael Haydn. He first appeared in public as a soloist on the violin at the age of seven. Moving to Vienna in 1790 he visited Mozart and may have taken lessons from him. Although he dedicated his 1798 sonatas op. 6 to Beethoven, the two were rivals. Beethoven however bested Woelfl in a piano 'duel' at the house of Count Wetzlar in 1799, after which Woelfl's local popularity waned. After spending the years 1801 -1805 in Paris, Woelfl moved to London, where his first concert performance was on 27 May 1805. 

Woelfl wrote six piano concertos, five symphonies, numerous string quartets and 68 sonatas for the piano, several for piano and violin, 18 piano trios, and seven operas. The first piano concerto is amiable stuff: poetic and suffused with charm and calm. Although but a slight side-step distant from Mozart, this and his other music is very fresh and engaging.
[Performance listened to: Yorck Kronenberg (piano) and the SWR Rundfunkorchester Kaiserslauten/Johannes Moesius]


(16) Anton Eberl: Piano Concerto in C major, Op. 36 (1803)
Anton Eberl (1765-1807) was born in Vienna as the son of an official at the imperial court. He was a musical prodigy, who performed as a pianist as early as age seven. At his father's insistence, he began studying law in the late 1770s, but he soon switched to focus entirely on music. He studied with Mozart and became friends with him. Eberl's compositions were of such a high standard that some were published under Mozart's name. Eberl openly protested against this misuse of his work. Upon Mozart's death, he composed the cantata "At Mozart's Grave." After Mozart's death, contact with his family was not broken: he accompanied Mozart's widow Constanze and her sister Aloysia Lange on a concert tour to Hamburg and Leipzig in the winter of 1795-1796.

On March 28, 1796, Eberl married Anna Maria Scheffler, and in the same year he left for St. Petersburg, where he was appointed Kapellmeister, composer, pianist, and music teacher at the court of Tsar Paul I.

Eberl devoted himself to composing instrumental music and became immensely popular with it. His Symphony in E-flat premiered on April 7, 1805 at the same time as Beethoven's Third Symphony (Eroica), with Eberl receiving the best reviews. Unfortunately, Eberl was a genius who died young of blood-poisoning.

The present piano concerto was premiered by Eberl himself in 1803. The closeness to Mozart is unmistakable. In all, Eberl wrote four piano concertos and five symphonies, and further a large amount of piano music.
[Performance listened to: James McChesney with the Slovak Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Karl Kemper]


(17) Ferdinand Ries: Piano Concerto No. 4 in C minor, Op. 115 (1809)
Ferdinand Ries (1784-1838) was Beethoven's favorite pupil and scretary and has long stood in the shadow of the master. He composed eight symphonies, a violin concerto, nine piano concertos, three operas, and numerous other works, including 26 string quartets. In 1838 he published a collection of reminiscences of his teacher Beethoven, co-written with Franz Wegeler. He wrote in a style which lies between the Classical and early Romantic styles. His concert trips took Ries through the whole of Europe, with an extended stay of eleven years in London from 1813. After his return to Germany, he lived and worked mainly in Frankfurt am Main.

Ries completed the present concerto around 1809, before embarking on his European tours. This would make the concerto the second of the composers eight piano concertos. It is likely that he performed the work regularly during the next few years. As with other concertos by Ries, this concerto was only published much later, at a time Ries didn't need it anymore as part of his performing repertoire (which he kept out of the hands of other performers). If its orchestral fabric nods in Beethoven’s direction, particularly in the first movement, the piano writing is that of the younger generation, of artists such as Johann Nepomuk Hummel whom he must have met on many occasions in Vienna. This is evident in the Molto adagio second movement and in the unorthodox C major Allegretto finale which is interrupted by an Adagio leading to a brisk Allegro conclusion filled with dazzling bravura writing.
[Performance listened to: Christopher Hinterhuber, piano, with the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra conducted by Uwe Grodd on Naxos]


(18) John Field: Piano Concerto in A-flat major, H. 31 (1811)
John Field (1782–1837) was born at Dublin in 1782. He came of a musical family, his father being a violinist. When a few years later the family settled in London, Field became the favorite pupil of the celebrated Clementi, whom he accompanied to Paris, and later, in 1802, on his great concert tour through France, Germany and Russia. Under the auspices of his master Field appeared in public in most of the great European capitals, especially in St Petersburg, and in that city he remained when Clementi returned to England. In 1831 he came to England for a short time, and for the next four years led a migratory life in France, Germany and Italy, exciting the admiration of music lovers wherever he appeared in public.

Field became well-known for his piano style of a chromatically decorated melody over sonorous left hand parts supported by sensitive pedalling. Representative of these traits are Field's 18 nocturnes, which were some of the most influential music of the early Romantic period, and much loved by Chopin and Liszt. Similarly influential were Field's early piano concertos, which occupy a central place in the development of the genre in the 19th century. Already the earliest of these works show competent and imaginative orchestration, and bold, original piano writing. Composers such as Hummel, Kalkbrenner and Moscheles were influenced by these works, which are particularly notable for their nocturne-like central movements.

Field wrote his second piano concerto using the lyric, subdued, slightly melancholy style typical of the late Mozart, rather than the joyous "happy-go-lucky mood" of Haydn or the bombastic display of Beethoven. It is imbued with lyric themes and even instrumental embellishments which are reminiscent of those from the composer's native Ireland. In three different sections of the first movement, a lyric section with harp-like movements in the left hand is followed by a driving, audibly Irish-style reel. The influence of his mentor Muzio Clementi was also important especially in the more Romantic features of the work. It has consistently been the most popular of Field's seven concertos.
[Performance listened to: Paolo Restani with Orchestre Philharmonique de Nice directed by Mareo Guidarini (Brilliant Classics)]

(19) Johann Nepomuk Hummel: Piano Concerto in C, Op. 34 (ca. 1812)
Hummel (1778-1837) has already often been mentioned in these pages about classical music, as the unjustly forgotten pianist and composer who, being an important pupil of Mozart, carried Mozart's heritage into the 19th century. Hummel also studied with Haydn, Albrechtsberger and Salieri. Haydn recommended Hummel as his successor as Kapellmeister in Eisenstadt. After marrying a well-known singer - who was also admired by Beethoven (for more than musical reasons) - he in 1819 became grand-ducal Kapellmeister in Weimar. During his life, Hummel was showered with honors. There are about eighteen works for solo piano and orchestra in Hummel’s output, of which eight are concertos. However, No 1 Op 73 which was published in 1816 is in fact an arrangement of the Mandolin Concerto of 1799. If we disqualify that adaptation, the present work (Op.34/34a/36 in C) dating from 1809 - dedicated to Archduke Rudolph and published ca. 1812 - becomes the first mature piano concerto by Hummel. It received its first performance during the celebrations for the Archduke’s marriage. The work could be called Hummel’s "Military" concerto, not because it is in any way militaristic, but because the Napoleonic wars of the period seem to be echoed in its occasional use of soft timpani and muted trumpets, as Derek Carew, who wrote the booklet for the Chandos recording, so aptly formulates. These military tones are combined with typical Viennese lyricism. The ensuing Adagio is built on a chorale-like melody. The military spirit returns in the finale, but in a satirizing vein - the soldiers have been turned into toy soldiers.
[Performance listened to: Howard Shelley and the London Mozart Players on Chandos]


(20) Franciszek Lessel: Piano Concerto in C major, Op 14 (1813)

Franciszek Lessel (1780 – 1838) was born in Warsaw. His father was a pianist and composer of Czech origin who served as his first teacher. In 1799 Franciszek Lessel went to study with Joseph Haydn and continued to do so until Haydn's death ten years later. Lessel then returned to Poland, where he worked as a court musician, headed Warsaw's Amateur Music Society, and gave lessons on how to play the glass harmonica. In later life he largely had non-musical administrative and inspector jobs, but he always continued composing. His output includes - besides the present piano concerto - five symphonies, concertos for horn, flute and clarinet, string quartets and other chamber music, piano sonatas and church music.

Lessel's sole piano concerto is a brilliant work, with a particularly beautiful melody in the first Allegro movement. It sparkles in the piano and orchestral parts, but all the same both subjects of the exposition are in a lyrical vein. The Adagio is in an unpretentious song-like manner. The Rondo Allegretto is in a mazurka rhythm and here pianistic virtuosity reach new heights. 
[Performance listened to: Howard Shelley with Sinfonia Varsovia on Fryderyk Chopin Society]

(21) Franz Xaver Mozart: Piano Concerto No 2 in E-flat major (1818)
Franz Xaver Wolfgang Mozart (1791 – 1844), also known as Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Jr., was the youngest child of six born to Mozart and his wife Constanze. He was a composer, pianist, conductor, and teacher of the late classical period whose early Romantic style was heavily influenced by his father's late works.

Franz Xaver grew up in Prague under the care of Franz Xaver Niemetschek. Starting in 1798, the year Niemetschek published the first Mozart biography authorized by Constanze, Wolfgang junior took music lessons from Georg Vogler, Antonio Salieri, and Johann Nepomuk Hummel. He also began composing musical works at an early age. His opus 1 was published in Vienna in 1802, a piano quartet in g minor. Franz Xaver was eleven years old at the time. He gained some fame as a pianist fairly quickly, but remained in his father's shadow throughout his life, a situation of which he was painfully aware. He became a music teacher and chapel master in Lemberg (Lviv) and encouraged Ludwig von Köchel to compile a catalog of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's oeuvre. In 1838 Franz Xaver settled in Vienna. He was appointed honorary Kapellmeister of the Mozarteum, which opened its doors in Salzburg in October 1841. Franz Xaver Mozart's oeuvre consists mainly of chamber music, songs and a number of piano concertos. The second concerto in particular shows signs of breaking out into the romantic era. It is unfair that this music has lain for so long under the shadow of his brilliant father.
[Performance listened to: Howard Shelley piano/conductor and the Sinfonieorchester St Gallen on Hyperion]







April 29, 2022

Ingeborg Bronsart von Schellendorf: Phantasie op. 21 for violin and piano (Women Composers 13)

Ingeborg Starck (1840 – 1913) was the daughter of Finnish parents. Having shown musical gifts from a young age, she studied piano with amongst others Adolf Henselt, before completing her studies in Weimar with Franz Liszt.

During a stay in Paris in 1861 her friends included composers such as Auber, Berlioz, Rossini and Wagner. In September of the same year, she married fellow pianist-composer Hans Bronsart von Schellendorff, a member of Liszt's circle whom she had met in Weimar. She toured Europe as a concert pianist until, in 1867, her husband became general manager of the Royal Theatre in Hanover. But she remained musically active, as a composer of 4 operas, a piano concerto, chamber and instrumental music and a large number of songs.

The Phantasie Op 21 for Violin and Piano is typical 19th c. salon music, a very romantic piece. It is played here by Mirka Malmi, violin & Tiina Karakorpi, piano.

Women Composers Index

April 28, 2022

Maria Bach: String Quintet 1936 (Women Composers 12)

Emilie Marie Baroness von Bach (1896–1978) was born to a wealthy family in Vienna (no family of Johann Sebastian!) and grew up at Leesdorf Castle in Baden. Her father was a lawyer, painter and violinist, her mother was a singer and composer. In the Bach family household, art and music were the linchpin of daily existence. Famous personalities, such as Johannes Brahms, Arthur Nikisch, Oskar Kokoschka, Gustav Klimt and many others, were among the constant guests. From the age of six Maria Bach received piano lessons at the Grimm Music School in Baden. Over the years she received several prizes for her pianistic skills. From the age of fourteen she also took violin lessons. 

In 1914, Maria Bach composed her 1st prelude. This was followed by songs and other piano pieces. On Sundays, Maria and her sister Henriette played at soirées organized by their family. In 1919, Bach began her composition studies at the Universität für Musik und darstellende Kunst Wien. She studied there with Joseph Marx, who helped her develop her own personal musical style. As a composer, Bach made her debut in 1921 with the song cycle Narrenlieder für Tenor und Orchester. Inspired by Joseph Marx, Maria Bach, who was influenced by late Romanticism, from then on occupied herself with Impressionism and the music of Mussorgsky, Scriabin and Stravinsky. In 1924 she wrote a sonata for cello and piano, in 1927/28 a piano quintet. Later followed a piano quartet, songs for voice and orchestra, chamber music and orchestral works. As a composer Maria Bach became more and more recognized, especially in Germany.

In 1952, Bach married Arturo Ciacelli, an Italian painter who taught at the Italian school in Vienna. Inspired by her husband and their travels in Italy, Bach painted Italian landscapes, and when she began exhibiting these paintings, they became extremely popular. In 1966 Arturo Ciacelli died, which meant that Maria Bach initially had no more creative energy. However, after some time she began again composing piano songs and cantatas. But times had changed and the public was no longer interested in Maria Bach's compositions, so her works were performed only in private circles. In 1962 she received a gold medal for her string quartet and in 1976 she was awarded the title of professor.

The string quintet from 1936 is played here by Christine Busch Violine, Elene Meipariani Violine, Klaus Christa Viola, Mathias Johansen Violoncello, and Conradin Brotbek Violoncello. The movements are: Bewegt, energisch; Thème e variations; and Sakraler Tanz. The highly nuanced tone colors of the string parts attest to a profound understanding of the technical and tonal possibilities of these instruments. In 1943 the critic and composer Fritz Skorzeny aptly summed up the fascination produced by Maria Bach's music when he wrote in the Wiener Tagblatt: »In Maria Bach’s oeuvre, manifold elements, exoticism, gripping writing, poetically inspired, are combined.«

Women Composers Index

April 27, 2022

Pauline Viardot: 6 Pièces pour violon et piano (Women Composers 11)

Pauline Garcias Viardot was a leading nineteenth-century French mezzo-soprano, pedagogue, and composer of Spanish descent. She stemmed from an artistic family and became the wife of Louis Viardot, a French scholar of Spanish art, who was not only an art expert and collector, but also writer of art books and travel guides, a literary translator, and a director of opera. Louis was 20 years her senior and did everything possible to support her career. Pauline's parents were both singers, and although Pauline was an excellent pianist, she was led to pursue a singing career.


Pauline Viardot made her opera debut as Desdemona in Rossini's Otello in London in 1839. This proved to be the surprise of the season. She had an exquisite vocal technique combined with an astonishing degree of passion. Renowned for her wide vocal range and her dramatic roles on stage, Viardot gave performances that inspired composers such as Berlioz, Camille Saint-Saëns (who dedicated Samson and Delilah to her, and wanted her to sing the title role), and Giacomo Meyerbeer, who created Fidès in Le Prophète for her.

The cosmopolitan writer Turgenev was in love with Pauline Viardot from the first time he saw her, and for decades he traveled with her through Germany and France, himself never marrying, living next door or later even in the same house as the Viardots, going from romantic involvement (he may have been the father of Pauline's son) to more quiet friendship, a relationship ignored or even condoned by her husband Louis - in fact, Ivan Turgenev and Louis Viardot were good friends who liked to hunt together. It is the most famous ménage à trois in history! (See the interesting The Europeans: Three Lives and the Making of a Cosmopolitan Culture, by Orlando Figes, https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4118854639). See also Turgenev's letters to the Pauline Viardot at Gutenberg.

In addition to Turgenev, Pauline was friends with a large number of European artists. George Sand was a great admirer of Viardot from the beginning, and later became an intimate friend; through Sand, Viardot also met Chopin. Alfred de Musset was also enthusiastic about her, which he showed in his newspaper reviews. Others were Clara Schumann, Gioacchino Rossini, Camille Saint-Saëns, Charles Gounod, and Hector Berlioz, the latter two of whom also fell for Viardot's charms. A salon was held in Viardot's house twice a week, where all these people and many others met.

Viardot traveled extensively and sang on all the major stages in Europe. She was very well known and loved in England and Germany, where she was on good terms with the royal houses.

Viardot began composing when she was young, but it was never her intention to become a composer. Her compositions were written mainly as private pieces for her students with the intention of developing their vocal abilities. She did the bulk of her composing after her retirement at Baden-Baden. However, her works were of professional quality and Franz Liszt declared that, with Pauline Viardot, the world had finally found a woman composer of genius. Among her work are 5 chamber operas, of which 3 on texts by Turgenev. She also wrote numerous songs and instrumental works for the piano.

Pauline Viardot's "6 morceaux for violin and piano" date from 1868. They are here performed among a number of other works by the Centre Européen de Musique Bougival at a large Pauline Viardot concert. The movements are Romance, Bohémienne, Berceuse, Mazourke, Vieille Chanson, and Tarantelle. (The concert continues with other work by Viardot after these 6 pieces.)

Women Composers Index

April 26, 2022

Maddalena Sirmen: Duet for 2 Violins, from 6 Duets Op 5 (Women Composers 10)

Maddalena Laura Lombardini Sirmen (1745-1818) was famous not only as a composer, but also as a singer and violinist. Born in Venice to an aristocratic but poverty-stricken family, she was taken in at the age of 7 at a Venetian girls' orphanage where she received a thorough musical education. 14 years of study were required before she was allowed to leave the orphanage. At the age of 21, she received a master's degree and was permitted to continue her study with the virtuoso Giuseppe Tartini and practice music outside Venice. Her violin lessons with Tartini are attested to by a letter from him dated March 5, 1760, in which he describes to her his method of playing the violin. Today, this letter is one of the most important testimonies of ancient performance practice (text of this letter at Archive.org).


Soon after, in 1767, Maddalena Lombardini married the famous violinist Ludovico Sirmen, and the couple began traveling together. They went to Paris in 1768 where they delighted the audience of the Concert Spirituel; however, her solo performance outshined their joint performance. She was a versatile soloist on both the violin and the harpsichord.

Ludovico seems to have encouraged Maddalena in her musical endeavors, and he respected his wife's work and was pleased to see her as a successful soloist. In time, she established a reputation as one of the best and most famous of the composers and violinists educated at a Venetian girls' orphanage. Maddalena and Ludovico Sirmen had one daughter. Maddalena independently managed and increased her fortune during her successful career. However, with the collapse of the Venetian economy due to Napoleon's invasion, she lost her fortune and died impoverished in Venice on May 18, 1818.

In 1771 and 1772 she visited London, where she debuted her violin concerto. In 1773 she also started a second career as opera singer. Among works attributed to Sirmen are about 35 works for strings, including sonatas for solo violin, duets for 2 violins, string trios, string quartets, and concertos for violin and string orchestra. Most of Maddalena's works date from the beginning of her career (or even the time she was at the orphanage) and were published in the years 1770-1776.

Her compositions are partly built on older examples, and partly contemporary in character. The influence of Martini, Bertoni, Tartini and his pupil Alberghi as well as indirectly Corelli are recognizable in her work. The strong dynamics in combination with the strong rhythmics are seen as modern for her time, as are the unexpected syncopations and abrupt shifts in the harmony. She often repeated the same motifs, making them function as a kind of signature. Her 6 string quartets are now considered to be of considerable importance in the history of the string quartet, like Joseph Haydn's String Quartets op. 9, which appeared simultaneously in Paris.

It is likely that Lombardini Sirmen played a violin of the Amati type. This would be evident from the fact that in her compositions the highest finger positions, especially the eighth, were not used. These cannot be played on an Amati violin, but can be played on violins by Guarneri or Stradivarius.

Maddalena Sirmen's Duet for 2 Violins (1775) is played below by Pekka Kuusisto and Annebeth Webb at the Prinsengrachtconcert 2019 in Amsterdam.

(Partly based on the Dutch Wikipedia article)

Women Composers Index

April 25, 2022

Henriëtte Bosmans: Cello Sonata (Women Composers 9)

I have to confess guilt: in my posts about Dutch music, I have failed to include Henriëtte Bosmans (1895-1952), even though she wrote great cello music.

Henriëtte Bosmans's parents were respectively a cellist (with the Concertgebouw Orchestra) and a pianist, so she had music in her blood. As a pianist herself, from the age of seventeen she performed regularly in the Amsterdam Concertgebouw. From 1914 she began composing pieces for piano and took composition lessons. In 1919 her violin sonata was performed publicly for the first time. She wrote mainly chamber music and songs and - after orchestration lessons in 1921-22 with Cornelis Dopper - also orchestral music, often with a soloistic role for the cello. As she strove to create more of a contemporary style, she apprenticed with Willem Pijper from 1927 to 1930.

In 1941, she was banned from performing by the German occupiers because she was half-Jewish. After World War II, she began to compose (almost exclusively songs) and perform again.

Bosmans had a remarkably modern style, in which she was inspired by the musical pioneers of her time - especially by Debussy - but still found her own way. From her teacher Pijper she adopted polytonality. Her music is also mainly impressionistic, with a predilection for unexpected twists in measure and key. She wrote sonatas for violin and for cello, two concertos for the cello, for the violin and the flute, a piano trio, a string quartet, and shorter pieces for cello and piano. Between 1920 and 1952 she wrote numerous songs, some even on (translated) texts of Chinese classical poets like Li Bai and Du Fu.

The cello sonata, written in 1919, is played by Lawrence Stomberg, cello, and Ketty Nez, piano. The movements are: allegro maestoso, un poco allegretto, adagio, and allegro molto e con fuoco. It is a very powerful work, with clear lines and sharp edges.

Article about the cello sonata by Bosmans.

(My introduction borrows from the Dutch version of Wikipedia)

Women Composers Index

April 23, 2022

Louise Farrenc: Piano Quintet No. 1 in A minor, Op. 30 (Women Composers 8)

Louise Farrenc (1804-1875) was active as a composer, virtuoso pianist and teacher. She was a woman in a man’s world. Clara Schumann had previously been the only woman to be praised for her compositions and performances; although her father and husband had prevented her from having a real career in music, she had to start performing when her husband was ill and unable to provide for the extended family he had founded. It was generally considered that to earn money from music was a masculine pursuit. Farrenc not only achieved the near impossible of getting her music published, but was awarded a piano professorship at the Paris Conservatoire

Farrenc studied composition with Reicha; her husband Aristide Farrenc was a flutist, musicologist and music publisher. At first, during the 1820s and 1830s, she composed exclusively for the piano. Several of these pieces drew high praise from critics, including Robert Schumann. In the 1830s, she tried her hand at larger compositions for both chamber ensemble and orchestra. It was during the 1840s that much of her chamber music was written. While the great bulk of Farrenc’s compositions were for the piano alone, her chamber music is generally regarded as her best work – it remained of great interest throughout her life. She wrote works for various combinations of winds and / or strings and piano. These include two piano quintets Opp.30 & 31, a sextet for piano and winds Op. 40 (which later akso appeared in an arrangement for piano quintet), two piano trios Opp.33 & 34, the nonet for winds and strings Op. 38, a trio for clarinet (or violin), cello and piano Op. 44, a trio for flute (or violin), cello and piano Op. 45, and several instrumental sonatas. She also wrote three symphonies.

Farrenc’s reputation was such that in 1842 she was appointed to the permanent position of Professor of Piano at the Paris Conservatory, a position she held for thirty years and one which was among the most prestigious in Europe. Although she was later forgotten as a composer (only to be rediscovered in our time), one can say that Farrenc, compared to other women as Clara Schumann and Fanny Henselt, at least had a very successful career in music - something rare for a 19th c. woman.

Farrenc's two piano quintets (with double bass, like the quintet by Schubert) are firmly rooted in the classical tradition of Schubert, Schumann and Mendelssohn. They are delightful, brilliantly scored works, full of instrumental virtuosity and melodic invention. The first quintet in a minor is the more solemn of the two. It is here played by the Ensemble Louise Farrenc: Katya Apekisheva Klavier, Mayumi Kanagawa Violine, Klaus Christa Viola, Mathias Johansen Violoncello, and Dominik Wagner Kontrabass. The movements are: Allegro, Adagio non troppo, Scherzo: Presto, and Finale: Allegro.

Women Composers Index

April 22, 2022

Élisabeth Jacquet de la Guerre: Trio Sonata No 2 in B-flat Major (Forgotten Music 7)

Élisabeth Jacquet (1665-1729) was born in a well-to-do family of musicians and instrument makers in Paris. She spent her early years as a child prodigy at the court of Louis XIV. Subsequently, she established herself as one of the most important concert artists and teachers of music in Paris, and became one of the most important French composers alongside Jean-Baptiste Lully. Excellent composer and harpsichordist, she was the daughter of organist and maître de clavecin Claude Jacquet.

De la Guerre, in addition to being one of the most important women composers before 1800, is one of the leading composers of the reign of Louis XIV; as a 10-year-old prodigy, she could already read the most difficult music from sheet, accompany herself on the harpsichord, and transpose in any key she was told. She was given room to develop her musical talent by influential people such as the Madame de Montespan and Madame de Maintenon. This allowed her to be at court and become one of the most important French composers alongside Jean-Baptiste Lully. Many of her compositions De la Guerre dedicated to Louis XIV. During her lifetime, de la Guerre was a celebrity, and her salon concerts and public recitals were praised in magazines. De la Guerre composed in various genres: opera, ballet, cantatas.


In 1684 Élisabeth Jacquet married the organist Martin de la Guerre, from a distinguished dynasty of musicians, and the next year had a small opera-ballet performed in the apartments of the Dauphin. In 1687 she published her first collection of harpsichord works (followed by a second collection in 1707) and in 1694 her opera Céphale et Procris was performed - the first opera written by a woman in France, but due to the complex libretto it was not very successful. She therefore abandoned dramatic music and focused on composing sonatas, a new and popular emerging genre. While De la Guerre was faithful to the Lully tradition, she was also sensitive to the Italian style of Corelli, which developed in France around 1700.

Her sonatas are considered triumphs of the genre. This is due to her development of the role for violin and the way she blended French traditions with Italian innovations. After her death, her genius in compositions, her creativity in vocal and instrumental music, and her variety of genres have been acknowledged. Her life and career success show that she was given a rare opportunity to succeed as a woman composer, and show that she took full advantage of it.

We have four trio sonatas by Jacquet de la Guerre, which were probably composed not too long before 1695. Note the expressive opening movements, as well as the incisive rhythms and the fugal sections of the fast movements. The French aesthetic is honored in the dances featured in some of the sonatas. The Trio Sonata No 2 in B-flat Major is played by Adriane Post and Boel Gidholm, violins; Lisa Terry, viola da gamba; Naomi Gregory, harpsichord; and Deborah Fox, theorbo.

Women Composers Index

April 21, 2022

Clara Schumann: Piano Trio in G minor, Op. 17 (Women Composers 6)

Clara Schumann (1819-1896), born Clara Josephine Wieck, was active as pianist and composer, when in 1840 she married the composer Robert Schumann.

Although many (including Chopin) spoke highly of her work, it was difficult for a woman in the nineteenth century to gain recognition as a composer. Music critics of the 19th c. were of the opinion that "of course" there could be no serious review of a woman's work "because one was dealing with a lady." Others wrote: "I do not believe in the feminine form of the word creator... and I dislike anything that even remotely smacks of women's emancipation." Such male critics were only willing to ascribe "reproductive genius" to the "fairer sex" - in other words, women were treated as birthing machines.

That was also Clara's fate. Despite her excellent education and genius for music, her husband Robert Schumann just saw her as a means to reproduce and make as many babies as possible - in the 16 years of her marriage Clara gave birth to 8 children (not to speak about the miscarriages she also had), so half the time of their marriage Clara was pregnant. Schumann also was very much against Clara's wish to continue her career as a pianist - he needed a housewife.

Clara unfortunately was not resistant against the negative opinions about woman-musicians - she gradually lost her interest in composition and even stopped completely after the death of her husband. Her piano trio is generally regarded as the high point of her work, although she herself said disparagingly: "Of course it is and remains the work of a woman in which power and here and there inventiveness are lacking."

Happily, this trio is still being played today. Clara Schumann composed it in 1846, a year of great stress for her. She and her family had recently relocated to Dresden, and her husband Robert became so ill that the burden of supporting him and their four children in an unfamiliar city fell mostly to Clara. She taught and concertized tirelessly, even performing a recital on July 27, a day after her diary hinted that she had suffered a miscarriage.

The Piano Trio is a wonderful example of the German romantic style, personal, intimate and never seeking attention for technical prowess. It is a brilliant composition, of a highly poetic nature. It is played below by the ATOS Trio consisting of Annette von Hehn, violin; Thomas Hoppe, piano; and Stefan Heinemeyer, violoncello. The four movements are: Allegro moderato, Scherzo - Tempo di Menuetto, Andante - più animato, and Allegretto.

The Creative Art of Clara Schumann, by Claire Flynn, National University of Ireland thesis, August 1991

About Clara Schumann at Interlude.

Women Composers Index

April 20, 2022

Lili Boulanger: D’un soir triste / D’un matin de printemps for Piano Trio (Women Composers 5)

Lili Boulanger (1893-1918) was the child of a composition teacher at the Conservatoire de Paris who was 77 when Lili was born, and a much younger Russian princess, who was a singer. Lili Boulanger grew up in a musical milieu, with  prominent musicians as Gabriel Fauré, Maurice Ravel, Florent Schmitt, and Charles Koechlin as frequent house guests.

Lili was not yet five years old when she accompanied her older sister, Nadia, to the conservatory. Soon she was taking classes in music theory and solfège. From 1909 to 1913 she attended the Paris Conservatory. Lili Boulanger became the first woman to win the Prix de Rome, in 1913.

Lili Boulanger had been chronically ill since pneumonia at the age of two had compromised her immune system. In part, lessons were given at home because of her weak constitution. But her sister Nadia always took good care of Lili; both sisters lived together in a shared apartment in Paris. Nadia Boulanger, who later made a great career as a music educator and conductor, continued to live in that same apartment until her death.

Among Lili Boulanger's larger-scale works are three settings of Psalms for chorus and orchestra, as well as "Vieille prière bouddhique", an "Old Buddhist Prayer".

The two-part work D’un soir triste / D’un matin de printemps was completed just a couple of months before Lili's death in 1918, the first half being the moving portrait D’un soir triste (Of a sad evening). Boulanger originally arranged the piece for cello and piano. The second half, D’un matin de printemps (Of a spring morning), is the sprightlier of the two works that make up this musical diptych, and was originally arranged for flute/violin and piano. Both halves were also arranged for piano trio and for orchestra.

The first piece opens with chords that gives it a processional air. The atmosphere is serious, even funeral. The writing is gradually enriched, showing a great sense of harmonic color. A form of transfiguration appears when, at one point in the score, a major key is reached. The main theme will return under different guises, "as a distant memory", before the "painful and calm" conclusion. The second piece is one of the few pieces of a slightly optimistic character by Lili Boulanger. The same theme as in the first piece is presented here in the guise of a lively dance, shaking out over repeated chords with rich, Debussy-like sonorities.

Here we listen to the version for piano trio, played by Gabriela Díaz - violin; Rafael Popper-Keizer - cello; and Heng-Jin Park - piano.

Women Composers Index

April 19, 2022

Best Piano Quintets

Of the various combinations of the piano with strings, the piano quintet has the greatest sonority and orchestra-like qualities - although, as this is chamber music, all players perform as soloists. The piano quintet was quite  popular in the 19th and 20th centuries and many great works have been written for this form of chamber music. I am a great fan of chamber music and especially of the piano quintet.

Although Haydn, Mozart and the young Beethoven already wrote important piano trios in the 18th century, the piano quintet was a bit slower in coming into being. That being said, already in the time of Mozart it was quite common to play piano concertos as home music in the form of a piano quintet (piano plus string quartet), and that custom continued well into the 19th century - also Chopin's piano concertos, for example, were additionally published in adaptations for piano quintet. After all, the only way to hear music in the age before there were recordings, was to play it yourself, if necessary adapted as home music.


The first original piano quintets (for piano and string quartet) were written by Boccherini at the very end of the 18th century and he must in my opinion stand as the genre's "inventor" (although mistakenly not generally recognized as such). He wrote 12 original piano quintets (two sets of six) in 1797 and 1799, where the piano and strings compete in an equal contest. Although Boccherini lived in far-away Madrid, as his quintets were published in Paris, they certainly didn't go unnoticed. It is true that he had several precursors, such as Giordani who in 1771 and 1772 published two sets of six piano quintets in London, or Vanhal who in 1784 published three piano quintets, but these works all have an  "archaic" character, as the strings are mainly used to fill in the harmony as in the in the 18th century so popular "accompanied sonata" - the voices are not yet independent. That Boccherini wrote the first real the piano quintets is not so strange, for he was a great experimenter who tried out many innovative instrumentations in his countless chamber works. And as a cello player he had a natural tendency to give more independence to the lower strings.

A further piano quintet on a rather large scale for this same instrumentation was written in 1803 by Louis Ferdinand, Prince of Prussia and a promising pupil of Beethoven and very original composer in his own right (unfortunately, the prince was killed in 1806 at a young age in the Napoleonic wars).

Parallel to these developments, a different type of piano quintet also came into being in 1799 when the Czech composer Dussek wrote the first piano quintet in the so-called "Trout instrumentation," i.e. violin, alto, cello and double bass, named after Schubert's famous piano quintet for this combination (Dussek's quintet was published in 1803). This instrumentation remained popular in the 19th c. and we have for example quintets by Hummel (1802), Ries (1817), Schubert (1819), Limmer (1830-1835), Farrenc (two quintets from 1840), Onslow (1846) and Goetz (1874) for this combination.

Schumann's piano quintet of 1842 is generally seen as a breakthrough, not only because it was a very influential work, but also because he again paired the piano with a string quartet as Boccherini and Louis Ferdinand had done (and of course others - there is, for example, a piano quintet for piano and string quartet dating from 1826 by the in Paris active Anton Reicha). Schumann's quintet had so much success (it is arguably one of the best works he ever wrote) that he has even been credited with the creation of the genre. As we have seen above, that was not true, but the artistry and high seriousness of the Schumann quintet were a quantum leap forward for the whole genre. Schumann's quintet was followed by Berwald (1853), Gouvy (1861), Brahms (1864), Franck (1879), Dvorak (1887) and many others, and the "Trout instrumentation" gradually died out. As we will see, the piano quintet remained very popular in the first three decades of the twentieth century, especially among French composers (for much of the 19th c., France used to an opera country where symphonic and chamber music was not popular, but this changed in the 1870s, when a new generation of composers started composing focusedly in these very genres).

Here is my list of best piano quintets - this time I have also included works by famous composers, for after all we are talking about the rare genre of chamber music, so even such major works are not really "world famous" and deserve some boost.



[Schoenberg]

1. Luigi Boccherini, Piano Quintet No 3 in E Minor G. 415 Op. 57 (1799)
The Italian composer and cellist Luigi Boccherini (1743-1805) had in 1761 settled in Madrid where he served at the court of the Infante Don Luis. After the death of his sponsor in 1785, Boccherini - whose fame was already of an international nature - was named court composer in absentio by Friedrich Willem II, the King of Prussia, but this patron died in 1797. This led to a flurry of compositions as Boccherini had to supplement his income. In that year, Boccherini wrote his first set of piano quintets which were published by Pleyel in Paris as Op. 56. The fervid experimenter Boccherini had created a new genre! In 1799, he wrote another set of piano quintets, Op. 57, which he dedicated to the "French nation and Republic" and sent to the French Ambassador in Madrid. These quintets are more elaborate than Op. 56 and also incorporate thematic references to France. The Quintet in E Minor is in five parts. It starts with an Andante lento assai which is full of dynamic leaps and features a second theme in the manner of a funeral march. This is followed by a graceful Minuetto (without trio)  and with no break follows the Provensal, an dance-like Allegro vivo that contains the most explicit reference to France. It is structured in the form of a Rondo with variations. The next Andante forms a sort of agitated recitative, and this leads to the fifth part of the quintet, which is a new reprisal of the Provensal and thus concludes the quintet. A very inventive and characteristic work, fully worthy of being one of the first piano quintets ever written.
Recording listened to: Zagreb String Quartet with Riccardo Caramella, piano, on Nuovo Era (with Piano Quintets Op. 57 Nos. 1 & 2).

2. Johann Nepomuk Hummel, Piano Quintet in E Flat Minor, Op 87 ("Trout Instrumentation," 1802)
Johann Nepomuk Hummel (1778-1837) was a child prodigy and pupil and housemate of Mozart. From 1788 Hummel spent four years concertizing throughout Germany, Holland and England. After returning to Vienna in 1792, he studied composition with Albrechtsberger, Salieri and Haydn. Hummel became Haydn's successor in Eisenstadt and later served as music director at the courts of Stuttgart and Weimar. Hummel apparently wrote the present Piano Quintet already in 1802, but only had it published in 1822, three years after Schubert's Trout Quintet. The main theme of the opening movement has a martial character. The movement is in very free sonata form, the second theme does not appear until after a mock "development." The Minuetto is a mixture of animation with melancholy. In contrast, the Finale is full of lighthearted merriment and leads to a brilliant close. A masterpiece that deserves to be better known, like all Hummel's music. Hummel was an important and direct link between Mozart and the Romantic period.
Recording listened to: Sestetto Classico on MDG (with Grand Sextuor by Bettini).

3. Ferdinand Ries, Piano Quintet in B Minor, Op. 74 ("Trout Instrumentation," 1817)
Ferdinand Ries (1784-1837) was Beethoven's most gifted pupil, and a fine composer and virtuoso pianist in his own right - again a composer who is today unjustly forgotten. Ries showed musical promise from an early age, before concertizing throughout Europe for a number of years. After that, he settled down in London and in his later years retired to Frankfurt. He wrote symphonies, piano concertos, but also a vast corpus of instrumental and chamber music. The present Quintet was written in London and performed with Ries at the piano. After a slow lamento introduction, containing some Hungarian elements, follows an exciting Allegro con brio in which one bravura passage for the piano follows the other, leaving little space for the strings. Here we have the admired piano virtuoso Ries in full force. The song-like Larghetto opens with a beautiful cello solo. The brilliant and dramatic Rondo finale follows without a pause - it is the most exciting part of the Quintet and again contains a brilliant piano part, although there is also a calm interlude that evokes a sort of medieval atmosphere.
Recording listened to: Ensemble Concertant Frankfurt on CPO (with Grand Sextuor and Sextet by Ries)

4. Franz Schubert, Piano Quintet "The Trout" ("Trout Instrumentation," 1819)
Franz Schubert (1797-1828) wrote his famous Trout Quintet for domestic music-making in the household of one of his sponsors, a rich amateur cellist called Sylvester Paumgartner, but the work was only published in 1829, after Schubert's early death. Paumgartner's house was located in Steyr, in lovely rural surroundings, and that may have contributed to the relaxed and warm atmosphere of the quintet. The work has the character of a serenade, also through the use of the double bass, which as we saw may go back to Dussek's quintet from 1799, Hummel's from 1802 (although that last one was only published in 1822) or Ries' from only two years previous. The expansive first movement makes play with the natural contrast between the percussive features of the piano and the polished qualities of the strings. The second theme has much spaciousness. This is followed by an ornamented Andante and an agile Scherzo. Next comes a set of variations on the theme of a song, "The Trout" by Schubert, that was very popular with the Paumgartners. The genteel variations are around the melody rather than on it, as it is played over and over without concealment. The bubbling accompaniment to the original Trout song returns in full force at the end of the set of variations. The quintet concludes with an Allegro giusto, full of good humor.
Recording listened to: Members of the Hagen Quartet with Andreas Schiff, piano, and Alois Posch, double bass, on Decca.

5. Louise Farrenc, Piano Quintet No. 1 in A Minor, Op. 30 ("Trout Instrumentation," 1840)
Louise Farrenc (1804-1875) was a virtuoso pianist and composer who had received lessons from Moscheles, Hummel and Reicha. In 1842 she was appointed to the permanent position of Professor of Piano at the Paris Conservatory, a position she held for thirty years. She composed in the first place for the piano, but also wrote chamber music and three symphonies. Her husband Aristide Farrenc established one of France's leading music publishing houses, the Éditions Farrenc, and also published her music. Louise Farrenc wrote two Piano Quintets, both the work of an accomplished‚ highly inventive composer. Both works have four movements following the classical forms and key schemes, but they are also characterized by a colorful harmony with a romantic sweep. The piano is the leader of the ensemble‚ sometimes even in a virtuoso way, for example in the opening Allegro of the First Quintet. The slow movement of that quintet has a dreamlike, Schumannesque opening theme in the high register of the cello. The following Scherzo is high-spirited and memorable. The finale concludes with a buoyant theme.
Recording listened to: Linos Ensemble on CPO (with Piano Quintet No 2).


6. Robert Schumann, Piano Quintet in E-flat major, Op. 44 (1842)
Robert Schumann (1810-1856) began his career chiefly as a composer for the piano, and it was only in the 1840s that he tried his hand at orchestral music (including a piano concerto) and chamber music. In fact, prior to 1842, Schumann had published no chamber music at all, but in this year alone he would compose three string quartets, a piano quintet, a piano quartet, and the Phantasiestücke for piano trio. In writing his Piano Quintet Schumann may have been inspired by Schubert's second Piano Trio in E Flat major, as there some structural resemblances. The reason he opted for a string quartet next to the piano instead of continuing to write a piano quintet with double bass as had become customary in the early 19th century, was probably due to the cultural prestige the string quartet had achieved by this time as the most prestigious chamber ensemble, as well as the increased dynamic range of the piano which made a double bass unnecessary. The work was dedicated to his wife Clara, a renowned pianist, but she was ill during the first performance and Mendelssohn had to step in and sight-read the difficult piano part. The opening Allegro brilliante is characterized by two contrasting themes, an energetic, upward leaping theme, and a meltingly romantic second theme. The second movement is a funeral march, like in Schubert's trio mentioned above, but also reminiscent of the funeral march in Beethoven's Third Symphony (both are in C Minor). The theme is used in Bergman's film Fanny and Alexander. The third movement is a lively Scherzo with two trios and the final Allegro ma non troppo ends by combining its main theme with that of the first movement in a double fugue.
Recording listened to: Artis Quartett with Stefan Vladar, piano, on Sony Classics (with the Piano Quintet by Brahms).


7. Louis Théodore Gouvy, Piano Quintet Op 24 (1861)
Louis Théodore Gouvy (1819-1898) was born in the border region between Germany and France and shared both cultures. Educated at the conservatoire in Paris, he spent most of his working life in Germany as there was little interest in symphonic music and chamber music in "opera-crazy" France. But Gouvy's music is characterized by French spirit and suavity, rather than German heaviness. The Piano Quintet starts with a joyous and dynamic Allegro giocoso. It is characterized by a continuous eight-note pattern that keeps moving things along at fast speed. The first theme is utterly charming and the second theme in the cello is sweet and warm. The slow movement is a Larghetto mosso, a sort of berceuse with an intriguing dream atmosphere. The third and last movement provides a brilliant conclusion in the form of a Rondo with a stirring refrain. This is a quintet chock-full of lovely and captivating melodies.
Recording listened to: The Denis Clavier Quartet with Dimitris Saroglou, piano, on K617 (with art songs and string quartet).


8. Johannes Brahms, Piano Quintet in F Minor Op. 34 (1864)
Johannes Brahms (1833-1897) advanced the compositional ethic of the great Classical composers into the late-Romantic era and was one of the most influential German / Austrian composers, until will into the twentieth century. Brahms was enthusiastically promoted by Schumann and he remained a life-long friend of Schumann's wife Clara after that composer's death. Clara Schumann also played a role in the long and difficult gestation of the present piano quintet. Brahms had originally written it as a string quintet in 1862, but the famous violinist Joseph Joachim judged it too difficult and lacking in tonal appeal. Brahms then reworked it into a Sonata for Two Pianos and sent it to Clara, who answered that it was too full of orchestral richness to play as a sonata. That finally inspired Brahms to combine the piano and strings into the present piano quintet. The outer movements are more adventurous than usual in terms of harmony. The first movement starts with a strong unisono by all instruments, a sort of dramatic, theatrical phrase. The tempestuous and tragic movement is in tightly packed sonata form. The second movement is a tender Andante, the third one of Brahms' most electrifying Scherzos. The groping introduction to the finale, with its rising figure in semitones, is remarkable in its modernity. The body of the movement, in fast tempo, is a hybrid of rondo and sonata forms with a Gypsy flavor, but without losing the basically tragic tenor of this great quintet.
Recording listened to: Artis Quartett with Stefan Vladar, piano, on Sony Classics (with the Piano Quintet by Schumann).


9. Giovanni Sgambati,  Piano Quintet No. 2 in B flat Major, Op. 5 (1867)

Giovanni Sgambati (1841-1914) was born in Rome, to an Italian father and an English mother, and worked as conductor, pianist and composer in that city. One of the rare symphonists in Italy that was even more "opera-crazy" than France, he was supported by Liszt, whose works he frequently performed. Sgambati's most famous composition is probably his Requiem, but he also wrote instrumental music, symphonies, a piano concerto and chamber music. He wrote his Second Piano Quintet shortly after he completed his successful first. The opening movement is launched by a viola phrase against an tonally advanced accompaniment, which was a few decades ahead of its time. The movement with its flexible sonata form encompasses many moods, even that of a cafe-serenade. The second movement is a Barcarolle on a truly haunting theme. The finale, Allegro vivace, is a full of excitement and good spirits. This is an original quintet brimming over with lovely melodies and unusual rhythmic effects.
Recording listened to: Ex Novo Quartet with Francesco Caramiello, piano, on ASV (with string quartet Op. 17).


10. Franz Lachner, Piano Quintet No 2 in A Minor Op 145 (1869)
Franz Lachner (1803-1890) was born into a musical family (also his brother Ignaz was a well-known composer) and trained in Munich. He served as Kapellmeister in Mannheim and Munich. Franz Lachner was a prolific and famous composer, influenced by Beethoven and especially Schubert whose close friend he was in his youth, but also one who has fallen inexplicably out of the repertoire (or perhaps not so inexplicable: Wagner consciously worked to damage the reputation of the conservative Lachner, as he wanted the sponsorship of the Bavarian King for his own music). His Second Piano Quintet became instantly popular after its publication in 1871. Despite the date in the late Romantic period, the music reminds us that Lachner was a child of the late Classical and early Romantic era. The first movement is an unusual "sonata rondo." The main theme with is double content of latent power and lyricism is first presented on the piano before the strings join in. This lovely music is dark rather than tragic. In the ensuing Adagio non troppo the strings state the beautiful first subject. This movement has an almost Italian feeling. In contrast, the Minuetto has a more Bavarian flavor. The middle section includes an enchanting song for the cello. The finale is a genuine Rondo. The first theme scintillates in the virtuoso piano like a wild race, while the second theme is brought forth cantabile in perfect string quartet fashion. The quintet closes with a whirlwind coda.
Recording listened to: Orchester-Akademie des Berliner Philharmonisches Orchesters on Thorofon (with Nonet by Lachner).

11. César Franck, Piano Quintet in F minor (1879)
César Franck (1822-1890) was born in Liège, Belgium, but he studied and worked all his life in Paris. He was influenced by Bach and Beethoven, but also by Liszt. Besides his orchestral works and organ pieces, Franck was also an important composer of chamber music. His Piano Quintet is generally considered as one of his chief achievements, although it also has been criticized for its "torrid emotional power." The music has a cyclical character whereby a motto theme of two four-bar phrases, used 18 times in the first movement, recurs at strategic points later in the quintet. The first movement opens with a drammatico introduction and the ensuing music could not be more passionate and rich in dynamic contrast. It was rumored that the passion of the quintet (which in contrast to other works by Franck has nothing religious about it) was inspired by Franck's love affair with his pupil Augusta Holmès. The second movement, Lento, offers some respite and consolation. The finale, Allegro non troppo ma con fuoco, is again filled with raw passionate intensity. The cyclic theme also returns, giving unity to the whole composition. The darkness of expression of this melancholy quintet has certain elements in common with the brooding, unsettled post-Romantic music of Schoenberg and Scriabin. It was too much for some of Franck's contemporaries: Saint-Saëns, to whom it was dedicated and who played the piano at the first performance, demonstratively left the score on the piano after the concert and seems to have discouraged its further performances. Today it is considered as one of the best piano quintets ever written.
Recording listened to: Ensemble César Franck on Koch Schwann.

12. Antonín Dvořák, Piano Quintet No. 2 in A Major, Op. 81 (1887).
The Czech nationalistic composer Antonín Dvořák (1841-1904) was active in all genres, from the symphony to opera and large-scale choral works, but he also wrote more than 30 chamber music works. His Second Piano Quintet belongs to the top of the canon and is a good fusion of Czech elements with an international musical language. It is a sunny quintet and the first movement possesses a particularly exuberant mood. The Romantic content with its impetuous interchanges of major and minor, emotion-laden harmonic modulations, organically related themes and protracted melodic lyricism is firmly lodged in the framework of a Classical sonata form. The Andante con moto is a Dumka in Slavic folk style, switching between melancholy and exuberance. Each time the Dumka melody returns its texture is further enriched. This movement adheres to the Classical Rondo form. The dazzling Scherzo has been modeled on a Bohemian Furiant with vital and springing rhythms. The Finale: Allegro keeps an unchanging pace throughout, despite the torrents of counterpoint, even fugue. It is in sonata-rondo form and comes to a close with a burst of brilliant energy.
Recording listened to: Emerson String Quartet with Menahem Pressler, piano, on Deutsche Gramophon (with Piano Quartet by Dvorak).


13. Ludwig Thuille, Piano Quintet No 2 in E Flat Major Op 20 (1901)
Ludwig Thuille (1861-1907) studied with Rheinberger in Munich where he himself became a teacher, of - among others - Ernest Bloch, Paul von Klenau and Walter Braunfels. He was a lifelong friend of Richard Strauss. Although he also composed symphonic works and opera, he concentrated on chamber music. The Piano Quintet No 2 has been called his greatest chamber achievement - its counterpoint and harmonic complexity are particularly skillful. The first sonata-form movement has a true symphonic sweep. This is followed by a passionate Adagio with desperate climaxes. The third movement is a sort of Ländler, but a rather aggressive one, to which the celestial trio forms a great contrast. The breathless Finale opens with a piano cadenza and culminates in the chorale-like melody from the second movement. A work of formal mastery and full of dramatic contrasts, that deserves to be heard more often.
Recording listened to: Gigli Quartet with Gianluca Luisi, piano, on Naxos (with Sextet).


14. Théodore Dubois, Quintet in F Major for violin, oboe, viola cello and piano (1905)
Théodore Dubois (1837-1924) studied at the Paris Conservatoire under Ambroise Thomas. Dubois was an important organist and also director of the Conservatoire. He composed mainly religious music, but also symphonies, concerts and chamber music. He also wrote important theoretical works on harmony and counterpoint. Although somewhat academic, his melodious and inventive music is unjustly forgotten, as will be clear from the present Quintet. With the addition of an oboe, the work has a rather unusual instrumentation, although the oboe can also be replaced by a second violin to have the traditional piano quintet ensemble. However, the work's interest lies very particularly in the way Dubois combines the timbre of the oboe with the string instruments. He favors the lower register of the oboe and has it project its tone over the ensemble in thematic passages. The first movement is joyful and optimistic. It is followed by an elegant Canzonetta. In the Adagio an expressive and emotional theme is contrasted with more objective material. The work concludes with a sparkling Allegro con fuoco. In accord with the cyclical tradition of the time, the principal themes of the previous movements return at the end of the work.
Recording listened to: Trio Hochelaga with Jean-Luc Plourde, alto, and Philippe Magnan, oboe, on ATMA Classique (with Piano Quartet by Dubois).


15. Gabriel Fauré, Piano Quintet No 1 in D Minor Op 89 (1906)
Gabriel Fauré (1845-1924) is the French master of chamber music, but also vocal music (a famous Requiem) and orchestral pieces, a pupil of Camille Saint-Saëns and later director of the Paris Conservatoire. Fauré wrote in a musical idiom all his own that was always fresh. The First Piano Quintet had a long gestation period, almost 20 years. The first movement is characterized by an austere and enigmatic mood: the opening theme is heard beneath a spray of piano arpeggios. This movement is an example of Fauré at his best, the parts intricately and seemingly effortlessly woven together into characteristic textures. It also has a song-like character. The Adagio has a basic binary structure and starts with the first violin floating above a descending cello line and the lyrical piano part. The finale features a strange archaic dance that keeps haunting the imagination long after the music has subsided. Fauré's music is unmistakably French with a strong kinship to both the urbane Romanticism of Franck and the cool sensuality of Debussy. He responded to the quasi-orchestral opportunities offered by the piano quintet with a wealth of inventiveness and melodic and harmonic inspiration. In 1921 Fauré published a second Piano Quintet that became even more famous than the present one.
Recording listened to: Domus with Anthony Marwood, violin, on Hyperion (with Piano Quintet No 2 by Fauré).

16. Adolphe Biarent, Piano Quintet in B minor (1913-14)
Adolphe Biarent (1871-1916) was born in Charleroi in Belgium and studied at the conservatories of Brussels and Ghent before becoming a music teacher in his hometown. As he died young and didn't work in one of the main European musical centers, he remained almost totally unknown, but has written some interesting music that was inspired by César Franck, especially the 1879 Quintet and Violin Sonata. The Piano Quintet is an dense and restless work, full of unsettledness and unease due to the constant tonal modulation. The first movement seems to have absorbed the usual second, slow movement. It is music that moves through various adventurous sections before arriving at a radiant B major. The tormented, central Intemezzo starts with an ominous piano figure. The powerful Finale is again an instrumental strife of light against dark. An intense and absorbing work.
Recording listened to: Quatuor Danel with Diane Andersen, piano, on Cypres (with cello Sonata). 


17. Louis Vierne, Piano Quintet in C Minor Op. 42 (1918)
Louis Vierne (1870-1937) was a French organist (student of Widor) and composer, who had a rather tragic life. From his birth, he was almost blind and he used Braille to compose. In WWI, he lost a brother and a son on the battle field. He died at the console of the organ of the Notre-Dame, when during an organ concert he suffered a stroke. Vierne mainly wrote organ music, but also chamber works and a symphony. The Piano Quintet was written as a musical votive offering in memory of the death in battle of his son Jacques. It is powerful music of vast proportions, but also with much tenderness. Vierne seems to have poured all his despair and anguish into the work. The first movement is opened by a short introduction played essentially on the piano, after which two very intense main themes grow in sublime sentiment, until ending in serenity. In the ensuing Larghetto the viola plays a sorrowful melody and tension lurks beneath the apparent calm. The finale alternates fugal sections with scherzo-like blasts of anger. It is a violent movement inspired by a sort of somber heroism, ending on powerful C Minor chords. A tragic, but dignified work.
Recording listened to: Quatuor Atheneum Tacchino with Gabriel Tacchino, piano, on Disques Pierre Verany (with String Quartet by Vierne).


18. Edward Elgar, Piano Quintet in A Minor Op 84 (1919)
Edward Elgar (1857-1934) is today one of the best known English composers. He was a violinist and organist; as composer he was self-taught. In Victorian and Edwardian England, he was an outsider both socially (as a Roman Catholic from a poor family) and musically (his musical influences were from continental Europe). Elgar is known for his large-scale oratorios and orchestral music, but he also left a fine body of more intimate chamber music. The Piano Quintet was written in 1918, when Elgar spent a peaceful summer in a cottage in Sussex. The first movement has been called "ghostly music," starting in a magical way by confronting a slow piano theme reflecting the plainsong "Salve Regina" with insistent stabbing strings. The second subject is a Spanish-sounding, languorous dance. The slow movement banishes all specters and spins on in an expansive and reassured way, a center of romantic stillness. But in the finale, which starts vigorously enough, the specters gradually return, undermining confidence, until blown away by the recapitulation of the handsome first theme. The quintet has been linked to a legend about some sinister, twisted trees standing near the cottage where Elgar stayed during composition: these were associated with a legend about Spanish monks struck by lightning while performing a blasphemous dance. An ambitious and expansive work.
Recording listened to: Coull String Quartet with Allan Schiller, piano, on ASV (with Piano Quintet in D Minor by Bridge).


19. Reynaldo Hahn, Piano Quintet in F Sharp Minor (1921)
Reynaldo Hahn (1874-1947) was born in Venezuela from a German-Jewish father and a Venezuelan mother of Spanish-Basque origin. Hahn’s family moved to Paris when he was three and he studied at the Conservatory under Massenet. The flamboyant Hahn drew his friends from a wide cultural circle and was, for example, a life-long friend (and one-time lover) of the famous writer Marcel Proust. Hahn was especially famous for his art songs on texts by Hugo and Verlaine. He also left an interesting body of chamber music, of which the piano quintet (although today forgotten) was the most popular item during his lifetime. It starts with a big-boned and dramatic movement, Molto agitato e con fuoco, brilliant and impressive music that deserves to be better known. This is followed by a pensive Andante, with the sun only briefly shining through the clouds. The final Allegretto grazioso is elegant and genteel, almost like a piece of Rococo music. In this quintet we are miles away from the Groupe des Six - instead, the work seems a continuation of the Belle Epoque, nourished by Classicism, but also full of elusive regret.
Recording listened to: Quatuor Parisii with Alexandre Tharaud, piano, on Naive (with two string quartets by Hahn, all world premiere recordings).


20. Jean Cras, Piano Quintet (1922)
Jean Cras (1879-1932) was a 20th-century French composer and career naval officer, rising to the rank of Rear Admiral. He was born in Brest (Brittany) and in his music was inspired both by his native area as well as his sea voyages and travels to Africa. Initially self-taught, in 1899 Cras had the opportunity to study with Henri Duparc. The Piano Quintet (which also exists in a version where one violin is replaced by the flute and the piano by the harp) was composed while at sea and shows this inspiration in the short program notes Cras wrote for it. The first movement is clear and joyous, "the intoxication of breathing pure sea air." There is a vaguely jazzy quality to it. The calm second movement represents the "intense poetry" of an evening in Africa. The animated third movement is a sort of scherzo, representing "the rich musical intensity of an Arab town." It contains a clear oriental chant. The vigorous and triumphant finale represents the return voyage, "liberated by the open space from the petty things of life." Romantic and impressionistic at the same time, this is wonderful music. Cras himself regarded chamber music as his forte, a "refined musical form that for me has become the most essential."
Recording listened to: Quatuor Louvigny with Alain Jacquon, piano, on Timpani (with String Quartet by Cras).

21. Ernest Bloch, Piano Quintet No. 1 (1923)
Ernest Bloch (1880-1959) was a Swiss-born American composer. Bloch studied at the conservatory of Brussels. In 1916 he moved to the United States, working in Cleveland and San Francisco, until finally becoming a lecturer at the University of California, Berkeley. His First Piano Quintet, one of his greatest achievements, was written in Cleveland in 1923. The first movement seems dictated by obstinate forces bursting with energy. Material in a grim tone brought in a somber whirl of the strings is contrasted with more reflective and meditative passages. To accentuate color in the chromatic glissandi even quarter tones are used. Although there is no program, the first motif seems based on a tune that for Bloch represented "revolt against arbitrary authority." This is followed by a dreamy, mystic and fantastic Andante. It is haunted music about "magical islands in the Pacific." The finale, Allegro energico, is full of barbaric frenzy, as of a wild joy, but interspersed with a quivering, mysterious meditation. We can hear bird calls, again in quarter tones. A majestic section of symphonic power then leads to a calm epilogue with a viola melody of liberating relaxation. One of the most dramatic chamber pieces ever written, a work of exceptional mastery.
Recording listened to: The Kocian Quartet with Ivan Klansky, piano, on Praga Digitals (with Piano Quintet No. 2).

22. Franz Schmidt, Piano Quintet in G Major (1926)
Franz Schmidt (1874-1939) was born in Pressburg (now Bratislava) from Hungarian parents. He studied with Fuchs and Bruckner at the Vienna Conservatory. For many years he played the cello in the Vienna Court Opera Orchestra under Gustav Mahler. In 1914 he became Professor of the piano at the Vienna Conservatory. Schmidt wrote in a late-Romantic idiom based on the Viennese classical tradition, and left four symphonies, two operas, an oratorio and a small body of fine chamber music. The Piano Quintet was written for the pianist Paul Wittgenstein, who had lost his right arm in WWI. The quintet has an unmistakable Viennese flavor. The concentrated first movement is followed by a lovely, good-natured Ländler. The third, slow movement also contains a bubbling dance and the Finale is in Rondo-form.
Recording listened to: The Vienna Philharmonia Quintet on Decca (with String Quintet by Bruckner).

23. Julius Röntgen: Piano Quintet in A minor op. 100 (1927)
German-born, Leipzig-educated Julius Röntgen was a crucial figure in the music life of his adopted city Amsterdam from 1878 to 1932. Röntgen composed more than 650 works, many of which survive only in manuscript; there is an overwhelming number of chamber works, including 14 piano trios, 16 string trios, over 20 string quartets, and three piano quintets - these works were often written to be played by Röntgen himself with musician friends (including Pablo Casals) and his family members. The first movement, Andante, of the present piano quintet starts with a soaring melody that is checked by a characteristic, persistent seesawing figure, that creates an apprehensive atmosphere. The melting sequences give the music an unforgettable character. Although there are echoes of Brahms in Röntgen's music, this is very different from conventional Romanticism as expectations are constantly undermined in a modern fashion. The second movement is a motoric Allegro. This is followed by a Lento after which the finale in the end brings us back to the opening theme of the first movement in a questing atmosphere. A sophisticated case of thematic integration.
Recording listened to: Arc Ensemble (Artists of the Royal Conservatory of Music, Canada) on RCA Red Seal (with other chamber music by Röntgen under the overall title "Right Through the Bone" an allusion to that other, more famous Röntgen).


24. Dmitri Shostakovich, Piano Quintet in G Minor Op. 57 (1940)
Dimitri Shostakovich (1906-1975) was one of the most important of 20th-century composers and much of his chamber music displays his genius at its highest level. His 1940 Piano Quintet is widely regarded as one of the greatest examples of its genre. It was premiered at the Moscow Conservatory by the Beethoven Quartet with Shostakovich at the piano. According to reports of his playing, the composer played with restraint, emphasizing the motoric elements and excluding  any emotional exaggeration. The work has five movements. After a Prelude led by an improvisatory flourish from the piano follows a long Adagio in the form of a four-voiced Fugue. It begins on muted strings and is played like an utterance from which all emotion has been drained. This is followed by a garish, whirlwind Scherzo, as we also know from Shostakovich' symphonies. The next movement is an unhurried Intermezzo, basically consisting of a single line of music over a gently walking bass. In the genial Allegretto finale previous ideas are recalled until the smiling music ends almost too gently on G major. This is a work of great emotional power and unusual purity, one of the best quintets ever written.
Recording listened to: The Borodin Trio with Mimi Zweig (violin) and Jerry Horner (viola) on Chandos (with Piano Trio No. 2).

25. Nikolai Medtner, Piano Quintet in C Major Op. Posth. (1949)
Nikolai Medtner (1880-1951), a younger contemporary of Rachmaninoff and Scriabin, studied at the Moscow Conservatory, among others under Taneyev. With the help of Rachmaninoff, Medtner left the Soviet Union in 1924; after a sojourn in Canada and the U.S., he finally settled down in England. Although he was an excellent pianist, he choose for a career as a composer. His works include piano sonatas, three piano concertos and chamber works. The Piano Quintet was published after the composer's death. Medtner considered it the ultimate summary of his musical life and worked on it throughout his life. It has an unusual structure, starting with a broad introduction on an epic theme. Then follows a section which reminds one of the Dies Irae. In contrast, the Maestoso section introduces a theme of hope. The second movement is characterized by a tragic but beautiful melody, rooted in music of the Russian Orthodox Church. The Finale forms a synthesis which sums up the whole work. It is written in very complicated sonata form and also demonstrates the mastery of counterpoint by Medtner. The coda brings a hymn that is full of light and joy.
Recording listened to: Dmitri Alexeev, piano, with the New Budapest Quartet on Hyperion (with Piano Concerto No. 1).
Chamber Music Index